Naturalizer Womens Samantha Comfortable Pointed Toe D'Orsay Slip On Ballet Flat

4.2 4.2 out of 5 stars 2,679 ratings

Sustainability features

This product has sustainability features recognized by trusted certifications.

Manufacturing practices

The leather in this product was produced by a Leather Working Group (LWG) certified tannery, supporting more-responsible leather production. LWG brand members may make on-product claims if they have submitted a sourcing declaration and if the product contains >50% leather, and 100% of the leather is produced by a LWG certified tannery.

As certified by
Leather Working Group Leather Working Group

Leather Working Group (LWG) is a not-for-profit community organization dedicated to driving excellence in the production of more-sustainable leather. LWG aims to have a positive impact on the environment through driving resource efficiency in leather production, reduced waste generation and emissions, better chemical management and increased traceability. LWG brand members may make claims on meeting a number of criteria, including submitting a sourcing declaration stating the percentage of leather purchased from LWG certified facilities. A claim can only be made when a product contains leather as the prominent material and 100% of the leather was produced by a LWG-certified tannery.

Learn more about this certification

Part of
Climate Pledge Friendly

To see product details, add this item to your cart. You can always remove it later.
:
*

Free 7-day try-on available for some sizes and colors.
Free shipping & returns.
Learn more

Black
Size Chart
US Slip On Ballet Flat -Regular
Brand SizeEU SizeUK SizeHeel to toe (in)
43428.3
4.534.52.58.5
53538.6
5.535.53.58.8
63649
6.536.54.59.1
73759.3
7.537.55.59.5
83869.6
8.538.56.59.8
939710
9.539.57.510.1
1040810.3
10.540.58.510.5
1141910.6
11.541.59.510.8
12421011
13431111.3
US Slip On Ballet Flat -Wide
Brand SizeEU SizeUK SizeHeel to toe (in)
4 Wide33.51.58.3
4.5 Wide3428.5
5 Wide3538.6
5.5 Wide35.5-8.8
6 Wide363.59
6.5 Wide36.549.1
7 Wide374.59.3
7.5 Wide3859.5
8 Wide38.55.59.6
8.5 Wide3969.8
9 Wide406.510
9.5 Wide40.5710.2
10 Wide41810.3
10.5 Wide41.58.510.5
11 Wide42910.6
12 Wide431011
US Slip On Ballet Flat -Narrow
Brand SizeEU SizeUK SizeHeel to toe (in)
4 Narrow33.51.58.3
4.5 Narrow3428.5
5 Narrow3538.6
5.5 Narrow35.5-8.8
6 Narrow363.59
6.5 Narrow36.549.1
7 Narrow374.59.3
7.5 Narrow3859.5
8 Narrow38.55.59.6
8.5 Narrow3969.8
9 Narrow406.510
9.5 Narrow40.5710.2
10 Narrow41810.3
10.5 Narrow41.58.510.5
11 Narrow42910.6
12 Narrow431011
To buy, select Size
Added to

Sorry, there was a problem.

There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. Please try again.

Sorry, there was a problem.

List unavailable.
Sustainability features

Sustainability features

This product has sustainability features recognized by trusted certifications.

Manufacturing practices

The leather in this product was produced by a Leather Working Group (LWG) certified tannery, supporting more-responsible leather production. LWG brand members may make on-product claims if they have submitted a sourcing declaration and if the product contains >50% leather, and 100% of the leather is produced by a LWG certified tannery.

As certified by
Leather Working Group Leather Working Group

Leather Working Group (LWG) is a not-for-profit community organization dedicated to driving excellence in the production of more-sustainable leather. LWG aims to have a positive impact on the environment through driving resource efficiency in leather production, reduced waste generation and emissions, better chemical management and increased traceability. LWG brand members may make claims on meeting a number of criteria, including submitting a sourcing declaration stating the percentage of leather purchased from LWG certified facilities. A claim can only be made when a product contains leather as the prominent material and 100% of the leather was produced by a LWG-certified tannery.

Learn more about this certification

Part of
Sustainability features
Climate Pledge Friendly

Product Description

Feminine meets contemporary With the samantha flats from Naturalizer. N5 contour technology. Leather, suede, fabric or suede and leather upper in a detailed dress style with a pointed toe. Slip-on fit. D'orsay-style side cutout. Non-slip outsole for stability, 1 inch hidden wedge heel.

Looking for specific info?

Product details

  • Product Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 12 x 6 x 4 inches; 7 ounces
  • Item model number ‏ : ‎ E7745L1
  • Department ‏ : ‎ womens
  • Date First Available ‏ : ‎ December 19, 2016
  • Manufacturer ‏ : ‎ Naturalizer
  • ASIN ‏ : ‎ B01NCOYCLR
  • Customer Reviews:
    4.2 4.2 out of 5 stars 2,679 ratings

Customer reviews

4.2 out of 5 stars
4.2 out of 5
2,679 global ratings

Customers say

Customers like the appearance of the flats, describing them as gorgeous, elegant, and sexy. They also appreciate the comfort, saying the leather is soft and breathable. Customers also like the quality of the shoes, mentioning that it feels well made. However, some customers have reported durability issues with the shoes beginning to wear out after the first 8-10 wears. Customers are also disappointed with stability, and blisters. Opinions are mixed on fit, and value.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

240 customers mention182 positive58 negative

Customers like the comfort of the shoes. They say that the leather is very soft, and the flats are very pretty. Some customers also mention that the shoes are wearable, but a bit large. The leather gives a little, and is breathable. The shoes also have a padded heel and toe, and are classy on.

"...The leather gives a bit and is breathable, and the elastic inserts were a stroke of genius design to keep these flexing instead of tugging at..." Read more

"...Perfect for work and extremely comfortable. I’m especially impressed with the quality. I walk every lunch break and these still look brand new...." Read more

"...They are good quality leather and suede combo, have a padded heel and toe, and are very cute and I was hoping they’d work out...." Read more

"These are great for work/school/business casual! I love the leather and suede mix. They look classy on and fit my foot great...." Read more

234 customers mention227 positive7 negative

Customers are satisfied with the appearance of the shoes. They mention that they are gorgeous, elegant, and sexy. Some say that the pointed toe is super flattering, and the color is good for their skin color. Overall, most are happy with the purchase and recommend them to others.

"...The pointed toe is super flattering and pairs perfectly with wide-leg pants, which usually make my short legs and small feet look swamped...." Read more

"...I walk every lunch break and these still look brand new. I would however recommend using some kind of protective spray for the suede...." Read more

"...quality leather and suede combo, have a padded heel and toe, and are very cute and I was hoping they’d work out...." Read more

"...I love the leather and suede mix. They look classy on and fit my foot great...." Read more

81 customers mention66 positive15 negative

Customers like the quality of the shoes. They mention that the leather is good quality, the stitching is quality, and the materials are great. They also say that the shoes are comfortable and are a great everyday shoe.

"...Perfect for work and extremely comfortable. I’m especially impressed with the quality. I walk every lunch break and these still look brand new...." Read more

"...They are good quality leather and suede combo, have a padded heel and toe, and are very cute and I was hoping they’d work out...." Read more

"Let’s start with why I love these... they’re gorgeous, the quality is good, they don’t slide on the floor, and the caramel color is unlike anything I..." Read more

"...Not true, I took the stuffing out of them. They have a wonderful insole and they are extremely comfortable...." Read more

211 customers mention114 positive97 negative

Customers are mixed about the fit of the shoes. Some mention that they fit as expected, with pointy toes that are not at all tight. However, others say that they run a little narrow and are too big.

"...The pointed toe is super flattering and pairs perfectly with wide-leg pants, which usually make my short legs and small feet look swamped...." Read more

"First I’d ordered my typical size, and they were almost too tight to even put on, so I returned them and ordered 1/2 size up...." Read more

"...I love the leather and suede mix. They look classy on and fit my foot great...." Read more

"Size 12W, it’s a little snug." Read more

26 customers mention13 positive13 negative

Customers are mixed about the value of the shoes. Some mention that it's comfortable, worth every penny, and a great buy. However, others say that it is not worth the money, sad for the amount paid, and that the shoes are not fit for sale.

"...I would consider this an average shoe for the price. Fits my size 12 feet as expected and is comfortable...." Read more

"I sent them back. They were really nice, but too expensive for the number of times I’ll wear." Read more

"...A fair weather shoe. Not for wet conditions. Comfortable. Good price too." Read more

"...probably would have bought a size under except that the price just doesn't match the value of the shoe compared to other models on the market" Read more

31 customers mention3 positive28 negative

Customers are dissatisfied with the durability of the shoes. They mention that it wears out faster than leather, and the tips of the toes wear out quickly. Some say that the shoes look super worn after a few months and are the flimsiest shoes they've encountered in ages.

"...means the shoe will probably fit more people BUT it will wear out faster than leather and it turns the right shoe into a flip flop for me..." Read more

"I’ve had these shoes for six weeks, and they have had very light wear. Barely any street walking. Worn on carpets in an office...." Read more

"...The flats did rub my heels raw because they were loose on me. I ended up putting heel grips on them and now they fit much better...." Read more

"...Shoes began to visibly show wear after the first 8-10 wears. After wearing them 15-20x, I am already searching for a replacement...." Read more

21 customers mention6 positive15 negative

Customers are dissatisfied with the stability of the shoes. They mention that the heels are loose and the shoes frequently slip off when walking. Some say that the rear quarter slid off their foot when walking, causing a crease. Overall, customers are not happy with the quality and stability of these shoes.

"...The flat is a little long on my foot so my heel keeps slipping out. To counter this, I put makeup foam pads in the toe box and use heel liners...." Read more

"...I got my usual size. They are wearable, but a bit large. Flopped around and made me feel insecure walking on stage...." Read more

"...why I love these... they’re gorgeous, the quality is good, they don’t slide on the floor, and the caramel color is unlike anything I’ve seen...." Read more

"...look and feel great however they are a little too big and flip off of my foot at times...." Read more

18 customers mention3 positive15 negative

Customers are dissatisfied with the blisters that form in the shoes. They say the material is sensitive and a perfect spot for a blister to form. They also mention that the shoes make sore rub marks on their toes and heels, and make the inside of their heels bleed within 5 minutes of walking.

".../inside of my foot feels like it a sensitive area, a perfect spot for a blister to form...." Read more

"...I tried to wear them as is and wound up with a huge blister on my heel from the shoe flapping off with every step..." Read more

"...sudden so lose the heel comes out when walking leading to blisters in less than an hour. Could not last an entire day with these...." Read more

"...was fine, but when I wore them to work for the day, my heels have blisters like no other! They stretched out quickly and rubbed so badly...." Read more

Quality but there are problems ... I’m sending them back ...
3 Stars
Quality but there are problems ... I’m sending them back ...
Let’s start with why I love these... they’re gorgeous, the quality is good, they don’t slide on the floor, and the caramel color is unlike anything I’ve seen. It has almost a shimmer to it.But there are unexpected problems that are why I’m sending them back:1) let’s start with the shimmer. It’s a love hate. Love because it’s gorgeous. Hate because it gives the shoes a blue cast in bright sunlight. Think pearly iridecent just not in your face. I was trying to buy a neutral shoe. But I also love the color. Just not what I was trying to buy right now.2) padding: I would rather have no padding than padding that doesn’t work with my foot. The pad that’s supposed to be for the ball of my foot is at an odd and uncomfortable spot for me. And because it’s not padding throughout, it’s a little bubble of uncomfortable.3) there is a bit of a small wedge hidden in the shoe. Take a close look at the pictures and your’ll see it. Maybe a half inch when you add the tiny heel that you see on the outside but I was looking for flats. This wasn’t a deal breaker but it did add to the problem with the padding.3) there is a tiny elastic gusset. Sure this means the shoe will probably fit more people BUT it will wear out faster than leather and it turns the right shoe into a flip flop for me (my right foot is slightly smaller than my left.) At the time I purchased this it wasn’t mentioned in the description and isn’t something you’ll notice in the pictures unless you are looking for it.These are a SLIM shoe. I expected this going in but I’m going to note it for people who don’t wear a lot of pointed toe dress flats. I typically wear an M width but in certain styles it’s a bit loose for me. I can not wear a W width shoe ever. This shoe in a M fits closer to a N. BUT it’s also leather which means they should stretch a bit on wearing them and conform a bit to your foot... if you can tolerate them for a day. Width was exactly as I expected it but if you usually wear round toes shoes, you might want to take that into consideration.So ... sadly they are going back. One of the surprises above wouldn’t have caused me to send them back (maybe the padding) but all three is just too much. The padding issue though will keep me from buying this style in the future. Honestly I was really hopeful I would love this shoe because there are so many colors!I have included photos though. No color correction done and you can really see how much the color of the caramel shoe changes with the change in the lighting and has a bluer cast to them with sunlight.
Thank you for your feedback
Sorry, there was an error
Sorry we couldn't load the review

Top reviews from the United States

Reviewed in the United States on October 5, 2022
11 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on September 13, 2023
Size: 8 WideColor: BlackVerified Purchase
Customer image
dan
5.0 out of 5 stars Perfect flats
Reviewed in the United States on September 13, 2023
Super stylish flats for work! I plan to purchase these in several colors! Perfect for work and extremely comfortable. I’m especially impressed with the quality. I walk every lunch break and these still look brand new. I would however recommend using some kind of protective spray for the suede. I wear a size 8 and found these to run a tad big, not big enough to size up as I personally have wider feet. I get compliments on them all the time. Love love love
Images in this review
Customer image Customer image Customer image
Customer imageCustomer imageCustomer image
7 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on May 4, 2021
Size: 6.5Color: BlackVerified Purchase
Customer image
4.0 out of 5 stars Run small, after getting right size, fit funny,
Reviewed in the United States on May 4, 2021
First I’d ordered my typical size, and they were almost too tight to even put on, so I returned them and ordered 1/2 size up. They are good quality leather and suede combo, have a padded heel and toe, and are very cute and I was hoping they’d work out. The point is good, there’s win for room around the toes so they don’t feel squished, but the fit feels weird. Where the shoe hits on the front/inside of my foot feels like it a sensitive area, a perfect spot for a blister to form. On the opposite side of the shoe, it connects all the way to the back, so it feels like there’d be less rubbing. I don’t like the off set feeling on my feet. I had to return them.
Images in this review
Customer image Customer image
Customer imageCustomer image
9 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on November 11, 2022
Size: 6.5Color: BlackVerified Purchase
3 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on April 4, 2018
Customer image
3.0 out of 5 stars Quality but there are problems ... I’m sending them back ...
Reviewed in the United States on April 4, 2018
Let’s start with why I love these... they’re gorgeous, the quality is good, they don’t slide on the floor, and the caramel color is unlike anything I’ve seen. It has almost a shimmer to it.

But there are unexpected problems that are why I’m sending them back:
1) let’s start with the shimmer. It’s a love hate. Love because it’s gorgeous. Hate because it gives the shoes a blue cast in bright sunlight. Think pearly iridecent just not in your face. I was trying to buy a neutral shoe. But I also love the color. Just not what I was trying to buy right now.
2) padding: I would rather have no padding than padding that doesn’t work with my foot. The pad that’s supposed to be for the ball of my foot is at an odd and uncomfortable spot for me. And because it’s not padding throughout, it’s a little bubble of uncomfortable.
3) there is a bit of a small wedge hidden in the shoe. Take a close look at the pictures and your’ll see it. Maybe a half inch when you add the tiny heel that you see on the outside but I was looking for flats. This wasn’t a deal breaker but it did add to the problem with the padding.
3) there is a tiny elastic gusset. Sure this means the shoe will probably fit more people BUT it will wear out faster than leather and it turns the right shoe into a flip flop for me (my right foot is slightly smaller than my left.) At the time I purchased this it wasn’t mentioned in the description and isn’t something you’ll notice in the pictures unless you are looking for it.

These are a SLIM shoe. I expected this going in but I’m going to note it for people who don’t wear a lot of pointed toe dress flats. I typically wear an M width but in certain styles it’s a bit loose for me. I can not wear a W width shoe ever. This shoe in a M fits closer to a N. BUT it’s also leather which means they should stretch a bit on wearing them and conform a bit to your foot... if you can tolerate them for a day. Width was exactly as I expected it but if you usually wear round toes shoes, you might want to take that into consideration.

So ... sadly they are going back. One of the surprises above wouldn’t have caused me to send them back (maybe the padding) but all three is just too much. The padding issue though will keep me from buying this style in the future. Honestly I was really hopeful I would love this shoe because there are so many colors!

I have included photos though. No color correction done and you can really see how much the color of the caramel shoe changes with the change in the lighting and has a bluer cast to them with sunlight.
Images in this review
Customer image Customer image Customer image
Customer imageCustomer imageCustomer image
169 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on August 10, 2019

Top reviews from other countries

Translate all reviews to English
Yvis
5.0 out of 5 stars Super cómodos!
Reviewed in Mexico on September 25, 2023
Size: 9Color: TaupeVerified Purchase
Ana Martinez
5.0 out of 5 stars Calidad y comodidad
Reviewed in Mexico on September 19, 2023
Size: 8 WideColor: TaupeVerified Purchase
Courtney Bastos
5.0 out of 5 stars Super comfortable
Reviewed in Canada on July 15, 2023
Size: 9 WideColor: BlackVerified Purchase
Jas
2.0 out of 5 stars ok
Reviewed in Canada on March 2, 2021
Charlotte
3.0 out of 5 stars Uncomfortable
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on September 27, 2022
Size: 8 WideColor: BlackVerified Purchase